THREADS - ESRI Discussion Forums

You are here: Home > User Forums > arcgis 9.3 release candidate forums > Thread Replies

ArcGIS 9.3 Release Candidate Forums

ArcGIS 9.3 Release Candidate: ArcGIS Desktop forum

Select by Location - Results Wrong	Gary Barden	May 28, 2008
Re: Select by Location - Results Wrong	Gary Barden	May 28, 2008
Re: Select by Location - Results Wrong	Brett Horr	Jun 09, 2008
Re: Select by Location - Results Wrong	Gary Barden	Jun 09, 2008
Re: Select by Location - Results Wrong	Brett Horr	Jun 09, 2008

Report Inappropriate Content • Top • Print • Reply
Subject	Select by Location - Results Wrong
Author	Gary Barden
Date	May 28, 2008
Message	Maybe someone could test this out. The attached JPEG show the results of a Select by Location for points within a selected polygon, using the "are completely within" and the having "Use selected features" checked. Thanks, Gary
	selection.jpg (opens in new window)

Report Inappropriate Content • Top • Print • Reply
Subject	Re: Select by Location - Results Wrong
Author	Gary Barden
Date	May 28, 2008
Message	Just figured out that it only seems to happens if there are multiple features selected for the layer that is being used to DO the selecting. If only one feature is selected the select by location seems to work fine. Gary

Report Inappropriate Content • Top • Print • Reply
Subject	Re: Select by Location - Results Wrong
Author	Brett Horr
Date	Jun 09, 2008
Message	If one were to 'Select by Location' using a single selected feature and then attempt to add to the selected features using 'Select by Location' with a different single selected feature, ArcMap will select far too many features in the targeted layer.
	Brett Horr GIS Manager Town of York Planning Department 186 York Street York, Maine 03909-1314 http://www.yorkmaine.org/planboard/index.htm

Report Inappropriate Content • Top • Print • Reply
Subject	Re: Select by Location - Results Wrong
Author	Gary Barden
Date	Jun 09, 2008
Message	I actually spoke to ESRI about this and it's a bug related to select by location using datalayers from SDE 9.2. It should be all set in the final release. Gary

Report Inappropriate Content • Top • Print • Reply
Subject	Re: Select by Location - Results Wrong
Author	Brett Horr
Date	Jun 09, 2008
Message	Gary, that is exactly what I am selecting against. Thanks for the heads up!
	Brett Horr GIS Manager Town of York Planning Department 186 York Street York, Maine 03909-1314 http://www.yorkmaine.org/planboard/index.htm