Customer Service | Training | Contact Us
You are here: Home > User Forums > arcgis desktop discussion forums > Thread Replies

ArcGIS Desktop Discussion Forums

ArcGIS Desktop - Extension - Network Analyst forum

Modelling for fuel consumption.   lawrence coe Nov 07, 2009
Re: Modelling for fuel consumption.   Joe Borgione Nov 08, 2009
Re: Modelling for fuel consumption.   Jeff Wickstrom Nov 09, 2009
Report Inappropriate Content • Top • Print • Reply    
Subject Modelling for fuel consumption. 
Author lawrence coe 
Date Nov 07, 2009 
Message Hi guys,

I'm trying to set up a VRP and want model fuel consumption for a waste collection route. I want to calculate a route that will use the least fuel based on fuel consumption calculated by taking into account the gradient of the road and the ever increasing weight of the vehicles (for which i have a series of equations) but i have no idea where to start.

So far I have created a 3D road network with calculated gradients and have made the VRP layer with all the necessary orders and depots, but I have no idea how to calculated the route based on fuel rather than time or distance..

Any help would be much appreciated.

Many thanks
Lawerence 
   
Report Inappropriate Content • Top • Print • Reply    
Subject Re: Modelling for fuel consumption. 
Author Joe Borgione 
Date Nov 08, 2009 
Message You may want to talk to your fleet manager and see what the fuel economy is for various vehicles are. Then you could use a time/distance impedance in the VRP as a surrogate for fuel consumption. 
  Joe Borgione
AlpineGeographic  
   
Report Inappropriate Content • Top • Print • Reply    
Subject Re: Modelling for fuel consumption. 
Author Jeff Wickstrom 
Date Nov 09, 2009 
Message Hello Lawerence,

With the vrp solver, you won't be able to model it in a dynamic way such that, for example, you only send the truck up the steep hill when light/empty. The same would be true for something like a weight restriction.

The vrp solver will minimize cost and you specify this in terms of a cost per hour and a cost per distance (for the routes). You can use this to indirectly minimize fuel consumption.

For the network dataset (drive time) attribute, use the slope to calculate the drive time. For example, slow down or increase the drive time for a steep hill. This will be considered in the vrp cost depending on how you set the cost per hour of the route.

Then set a cost per mile of the route depending upon its fuel consumption rate. With a mixed fleet, this will have the solution tend to favor the more efficient vehicles when there is a choice.

Based upon the result, you can report something like CO2 emissions based upon total mileage and your original assumptions for fuel consumption rate(s).

Jeff